Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Science Fiction > Fandom > Re: Anti-intell...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 53 of 69 Topic 6245 of 7425
Post > Topic >>

Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom

by goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (David Goldfarb) Feb 10, 2008 at 08:04 AM

In article <d40tq3t17sijblg44k69shovl1h0si4f8n@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>,
mike weber  <fair****tfan@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>On Fri, 8 Feb 2008 22:40:44 +0000 (UTC), goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>(David Goldfarb) wrote:
>
>>For myself, I think that Sturgeon's Law applies to criticism just as
>>much as to anything else;
>
>Sturgeon's Revelation, assuming you mean the "90%" routine.
>"Sturgeon's Law" is, in fact, something else.  I once read a fanzine
>piece by Sturgeon himself explicating this.

I'd heard about that one time, but I can't really bring myself to
care about it.  Sturgeon's Law is so banal that it's not worth
remembering (and the proof is:  I don't remember it); the Revelation 
is the insight that deserves enshrining as a Law.

-- 
   David Goldfarb          |"Ah, the stench of evil is about this place!"
goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
  |     "Actually, I think that's air-freshener."
goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 |               --_Zot!_ #4
 




 69 Posts in Topic:
Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Lee Ratner <LBRatner@[  2008-01-31 03:53:23 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
prd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (P  2008-01-31 12:37:00 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Evelyn C. Leeper&qu  2008-01-31 09:43:23 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
tchello_mesquita@[EMAIL P  2008-01-31 06:58:55 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
tchello_mesquita@[EMAIL P  2008-01-31 07:00:57 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
tchello_mesquita@[EMAIL P  2008-01-31 07:02:01 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Martha Adams"   2008-02-02 03:28:13 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Doug Wickstrom <nimshu  2008-02-11 20:02:07 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Lee Ratner <LBRatner@[  2008-01-31 10:23:52 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Andrew Plotkin <erkyra  2008-01-31 18:28:30 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
prd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (P  2008-01-31 20:54:00 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
djheydt@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-02-01 01:22:48 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
djheydt@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-02-01 21:15:49 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
prd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (P  2008-02-02 14:48:00 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Kay Shapero <kay@[EMAI  2008-02-01 21:24:27 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
prd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (P  2008-02-02 15:56:00 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Petrea Mitchell <pravn  2008-02-03 18:33:27 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
mvp@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (M  2008-02-06 12:00:24 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"pete-moss" <  2008-02-08 01:15:30 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Keith F. Lynch"  2008-02-08 19:43:48 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"pete-moss" <  2008-02-09 00:20:49 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
djheydt@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-02-09 06:00:20 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Petre Moss" &l  2008-03-08 01:33:21 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Tim Merrigan <tppm@[EM  2008-02-09 01:48:58 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Daniel Silevitch <dmsi  2008-02-09 13:08:04 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Keith F. Lynch"  2008-02-09 14:04:55 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Karl Johanson"  2008-02-09 23:56:20 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Keith F. Lynch"  2008-02-10 12:19:17 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Karl Johanson"  2008-02-10 19:36:07 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Doug Wickstrom <nimshu  2008-02-11 20:13:14 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
mike weber <fairportfa  2008-02-09 23:39:33 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Petre Moss" &l  2008-02-28 01:24:24 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Will in New Haven <bil  2008-02-02 19:03:28 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Lowell Gilbert <lgusen  2008-02-03 15:09:58 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Will in New Haven <bil  2008-02-03 18:52:03 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
trinlay <trin1066@[EMA  2008-02-06 12:49:47 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Tim Merrigan <tppm@[EM  2008-02-06 21:45:48 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
prd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (P  2008-02-07 10:54:00 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
mike weber <fairportfa  2008-02-07 10:45:21 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
David Friedman <ddfr@[  2008-02-07 12:09:01 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
mike weber <fairportfa  2008-02-07 16:29:10 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Tim Merrigan <tppm@[EM  2008-02-07 15:07:50 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
mike weber <fairportfa  2008-02-07 19:07:10 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
David Friedman <ddfr@[  2008-02-07 22:29:11 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Tim Merrigan <tppm@[EM  2008-02-08 03:56:55 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
mike weber <fairportfa  2008-02-09 23:41:04 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
winston@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-02-08 04:07:55 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
djheydt@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-02-08 05:18:57 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Per Chr. J." &  2008-02-07 15:44:18 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
David Friedman <ddfr@[  2008-02-07 22:11:56 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-02-08 22:40:44 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
mike weber <fairportfa  2008-02-09 23:42:49 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-02-10 08:04:33 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
mike weber <fairportfa  2008-02-10 06:16:15 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Will in New Haven <bil  2008-02-10 11:50:31 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
David Friedman <ddfr@[  2008-02-10 12:21:47 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Keith F. Lynch"  2008-02-10 16:49:40 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Karl Johanson"  2008-02-10 22:39:25 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
mike weber <fairportfa  2008-02-10 21:46:31 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Karl Johanson"  2008-02-10 20:34:53 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Doug Wickstrom <nimshu  2008-02-11 20:15:25 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Kip Williams <kiptw@[E  2008-02-11 22:48:14 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Will in New Haven <bil  2008-02-10 12:53:27 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
David Friedman <ddfr@[  2008-02-10 14:03:21 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Daniel R. Reitman <dre  2008-02-10 18:32:03 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Kip Williams <kiptw@[E  2008-02-10 21:53:27 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
Will in New Haven <bil  2008-02-10 14:06:32 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
David Friedman <ddfr@[  2008-02-10 15:53:08 
Re: Anti-intellectualism in fandom
"Pete.Moss" <  2008-02-11 18:57:14 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Fri Nov 21 1:56:24 CST 2008.