sethb@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(Seth) wrote in
news:fpkl2n$7nb$1@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> In article <1203365192@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>, Wayne Throop
> <throopw@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>>:: (again, as there are no schools where all the students are
>>:: required
>
>>In the hypothetical, the claim was that the potential berserk
>>with a gun has only two choices: he doesn't brandish it
>>threateningly, and zero people die, or he does, and one person
>>dies (that is, his own self). It's fairly legitimate to point
>>out that there are intermediates.
>
> In those cases, several people die, but fewer than if the
> victims weren't (required to be) unarmed.
>
That doesn't necessarily follow from the logic presented. (It does
follow, but for other reasons.)
--
Terry Austin
"There's no law west of the internet."
- Nick Stump
Jesus forgives sinners, not criminals.
|
