Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Science Fiction > Science > Re: Having seen...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 47 of 55 Topic 3493 of 3876
Post > Topic >>

Re: Having seen Iron Man

by naddy@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Christian Weisgerber) May 18, 2008 at 01:01 PM

John Schilling <schillin@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:

> Only for the narrow-mindedly literal.  The pronunciation of other
> words which start with *both* the letters "g-i", *and* the base
> meaning, "big/lots", makes things pretty clear.

That would be pronunciation by _analogy_ with other words.

> How do people learn English without understanding etymology?

Perfectly well, actually.  Native speakers have no inherent
understanding of etymology.

Etymologically, the prefix "giga-" is a modern coinage from Classical
Greek where it was pronounced with g-.

Here's a quick rundown of initial g- before front vowels (e, i) in
English:

* Old English g- became y-, e.g. "year".  This isn't spelled <g->
  anymore, so it is of no further concern.

* Germanic words that retain the pronunciation g- (e.g. "gift",
  "geld", fish "gill") are actually loans from Old Norse.

* g- to j- is a Romance sound****ft.  Words with that pronunciation
  were im****ted from French, e.g. "giant", liquid "gill".  This was
  then extended by analogy to learned Latin and Greek vocabulary.

-- 
Christian "naddy" Weisgerber                          naddy@[EMAIL PROTECTED]

 




 55 Posts in Topic:
Having seen Iron Man
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-05-11 16:06:30 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-05-11 16:06:58 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Ben Crowell <crowell08  2008-05-11 09:26:30 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-05-11 16:47:54 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Ben Crowell <crowell08  2008-05-11 09:56:02 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-05-11 17:32:35 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Ben Crowell <crowell08  2008-05-11 15:08:29 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-05-12 03:15:23 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Erik Max Francis <max@  2008-05-11 20:53:04 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-05-11 17:04:10 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Terry Austin <taustinc  2008-05-11 18:37:56 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-05-11 17:00:14 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-05-11 17:36:28 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Terry Austin <taustinc  2008-05-11 18:39:48 
Re: Having seen Austeniteman
Herr Oberst <nrvlaw@[E  2008-05-11 12:13:08 
Re: Having seen Austeniteman
Terry Austin <taustinc  2008-05-11 20:02:02 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
"nuny@[EMAIL PROTECT  2008-05-11 14:11:15 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-05-12 03:19:46 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Terry Austin <taustinc  2008-05-12 05:04:31 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Terry Austin <taustinc  2008-05-12 05:02:42 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Allen Thomson <thomson  2008-05-11 14:41:49 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-05-12 03:24:09 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Remus Shepherd <remus@  2008-05-12 14:29:00 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Steve Hix <sehix@[EMAI  2008-05-11 14:19:34 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
David Johnston <david@  2008-05-11 22:17:49 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Michael Ash <mike@[EMA  2008-05-11 17:24:50 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Dr J R Stockton <jrs@[  2008-05-12 17:04:28 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-05-12 17:34:27 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Dr J R Stockton <jrs@[  2008-05-12 19:31:44 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
mvp@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (M  2008-05-16 07:03:07 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Tim Little <tim@[EMAIL  2008-05-16 03:42:36 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Erik Max Francis <max@  2008-05-16 02:09:11 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Michael Ash <mike@[EMA  2008-05-16 04:24:03 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Erik Max Francis <max@  2008-05-16 02:41:07 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Michael Ash <mike@[EMA  2008-05-16 04:52:23 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Eivind <eivindorama@[E  2008-05-16 12:19:32 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Matthias Warkus <Warku  2008-05-16 15:44:02 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Eivind <eivindorama@[E  2008-05-19 09:40:54 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
George W Harris <gharr  2008-05-16 08:47:56 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Erik Max Francis <max@  2008-05-17 14:51:49 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
George W Harris <gharr  2008-05-17 20:05:12 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
John Schilling <schill  2008-05-17 06:34:41 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Erik Max Francis <max@  2008-05-17 14:55:33 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
John Schilling <schill  2008-05-17 19:26:28 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Erik Max Francis <max@  2008-05-17 20:59:26 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Michael Ash <mike@[EMA  2008-05-17 23:40:14 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
naddy@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-05-18 13:01:14 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
naddy@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-05-17 16:19:05 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Erik Max Francis <max@  2008-05-17 14:53:42 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Michael Ash <mike@[EMA  2008-05-17 20:33:44 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Erik Max Francis <max@  2008-05-17 20:58:21 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Michael Ash <mike@[EMA  2008-05-17 23:43:25 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
Erik Max Francis <max@  2008-05-17 21:55:33 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
mvp@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (M  2008-05-18 00:31:52 
Re: Having seen Iron Man
throopw@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-05-16 17:40:14 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Thu Dec 4 14:10:39 CST 2008.