Re: 4th Season Lost - Confirmed Dead - 5 star poll - SPOILERS AHOY !

"THullº" <XXthull1@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message 
news:XXthull1-513B09.10315009022008@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> In article <fdidncx-D4LXWDDanZ2dnUVZ_iydnZ2d@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>,
> "Arthur Lipscomb" <arthur@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>
>> "Darren Delgado" <darrendelgado@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
>>
news:fa554232-214b-417d-a7cd-dd1d7bffab85@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>> > On Feb 8, 6:49 pm, Captain Infinity <Infin...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
>> > wrote:
>> >> Once Upon A Time,
>> >>
>> >> tdciago wrote:
>> >> >On Feb 8, 7:17?am, jojo <jojl...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>> >> >> I had anyway a big problem that took .5 point (and maybe more if 
>> >> >> this
>> >> >> is really a mistake): the pilot of the plane was not Greg
Grunberg,
>> >> >> this is a major ****ing discrepancy !
>> >>
>> >> >If you're talking about the photo of the pilot in uniform, it was 
>> >> >Greg
>> >> >Grunberg.  With a mustache.  See
>> >>
>http://bp0.blogger.com/_RrObyQ3XzcY/R6VvhcBE19I/AAAAAAAASwY/Z69341sK_...
>> >>
>> >> >The mustache, of course, is not inconsistent, as he could have
shaved
>> >> >it any time between the taking of that photo and Sept. 22, 2004. 
>> >> >What
>> >> >*is* inconsistent is that the pilot's body in the wreckage was 
>> >> >wearing
>> >> >a jacket, and the pilot of flight 815 was not wearing one at the
time
>> >> >of the crash. So the wreckage was faked.
>> >>
>> >> Also, strong indicators that it was fake is the fact that the corpse
>> >> shown
>> >> was dead, whereas we saw the pilot alive on the island in the very 
>> >> first
>> >> episode.  Not to mention that the footage showed the plane under 
>> >> water,
>> >> though anyone who has been paying attention knows that the plane 
>> >> crashed
>> >> on
>> >> the island.  Also, duh.
>> >
>> > When spoilers came out about a second plane crash scene being filmed,
>> > there was a long discussion and debate about whether it's a fake
plane
>> > crash, or whether the Island or something else caused a disturbance
>> > that created a "double" plane.  The Orchid orientation video probably
>> > encouraged that line of thinking by showing a seemingly duplicate
>> > Bunny #15 causing chaos in the Orchid Station.
>> >
>> > That's why people thought (and some still think) the plane might not
>> > be a "fake".
>>
>> We already know time travel is a factor in this show.  And we already
had
>> one character seemingly travel back to before the plane crash.  What if

>> the
>> Oceanic six aren't six who were rescued but six who (after time 
>> traveling)
>> never got on the plane and tried to convince others not to get on as 
>> well.
>
>
> Then "We have to get back" wouldn't make any sense, since they were
> never there.....
>

True.  Unless they are referring to when they were there in the alternate 
timeline.  Besides I can't think of everything, it's the writer's job to 
retcon my ideas into the show so they don't contradict what was already 
established.   ;-)