Re: 4th Season Lost - Eggtown - 5 star poll - SPOILERS AHOY !

Scott Bryce wrote:
> cloud dreamer wrote:
>> Jack said two died after the crash...that Kate tried to save them but
>>  failed. They died before any rescue. Jack mentioned it simply to add
>> to Kate's character in his testimony.
>>
>> There is nothing...absolutly nothing....to indicate at this point
>> that 8 left the island in any official capacity.  The story they made
>> up was complete bull**** for a reason. We don't know that reason.
> 
> The reason I think the 8 initial survivors is significant, is that it is
> totally unnecessary to the made-up story.
> 

Not necessarily. We don't have enough facts to be going off speculating 
on it with so little basis. Maybe the rescuers found a couple bodies and 
they had to explain it. Maybe they found the diamond thieves. Maybe two 
of the losties were killed just before rescue. There are a wealth of 
explanations.

There is no reasonable basis to jump to the conclusion that 8 officially 
got off the island.

  ..


-- 

We must change the way we live,
    or the climate will do it for us.


    www.ipcc.ch/