Re: 4th Season Lost - Ji Yeon - 5 star poll - SPOILERS AHOY !

cloud dreamer wrote:

> noazdad wrote:
> 
>> "Dimensional Traveler" <dtravel@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message 
>> news:47dc9926$0$36395$742ec2ed@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>>
>>> cloud dreamer wrote:
>>
>> <snip>
>>
>>>> Oh come on! The kid still survived the flight. The point is they were
>>>> rescued as survivors of the flight. Some media outlet probably
labeled
>>>> them the Oceanic 6.
>>>>
>>>> The fact that Aaron was days from being born during the crash is
>>>> completely irrelevant.
>>>>
>>>> When the world first saw the survivors, they saw six. They were
>>>> labeled six as a result.
>>>>
>>> And never mind the fact that the woman claiming to be the baby's 
>>> mother was very definitely not in her third trimester at the time she 
>>> boarded the plane....
>>>
>>> -- 
>>
>>
>> Has Kate or ANYONE ever said that she gave birth to the baby?  I don't 
>> recall that ever being stated.  They say "you have a child", and 
>> "you're a mother", and Aaron calls her Mommy, but all of those terms 
>> are valid in adoption situations as well.  Maybe the story is that 
>> Claire survived the crash but died in childbirth, and Kate is 
>> "raising" the child as her own. Of course, Claire's real family might 
>> have something to say about that...
>>
>> I don't think they're even going to bother trying to develop a 
>> storyline where Kate is the biological mother of Aaron.  That would be 
>> ludicrous.
> 
> 
> Do you think the authorities would let a convicted criminal like Kate 
> keep a child that was not hers?
> 
>  ..
> 
> 
A) she wasn't convicted

B) what reason would they have to doubt her and/or do a DNA test, 
especially when none of the other O-6 seem to have contradicted her story.