Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Science Fiction > Written > Re: Comet impac...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 85 of 135 Topic 20587 of 22999
Post > Topic >>

Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of Evacuation

by goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (David Goldfarb) Mar 13, 2008 at 09:52 AM

In article <6ONBj.75858$pM4.66167@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>,
Bryan Derksen  <bryan.derksen@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>So I guess if you pile enough gamma rays into the planet enough will get 
>through to ruin peoples' day. But even if a typical GRB is likely to be 
>able to put out enough, I already accounted for that in part of the post 
>that you snipped; a gamma ray burst has a very brief duration so only 
>one hemisphere of the planet would be directly exposed. So it's still 
>not going to sterilize Earth.

According to Greg Egan, who I assume would have checked, it would 
dump enough energy into the atmosphere to make all or most of the
oxygen react with the nitrogen.  This would be Bad.  It probably
wouldn't kill the single-celled organisms in the lower crust,
but I wouldn't lay odds on anything multicellular living much longer.

-- 
   David Goldfarb          |"English cuisine is the cuisine of fear."
goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
  | 
goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 |              -- Andrew Conway
 




 135 Posts in Topic:
Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of Evacu
Matt Browne SFW <matt.  2008-03-09 10:28:42 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-03-09 17:37:33 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
David T. Bilek <davidb  2008-03-09 11:54:49 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-03-09 18:59:20 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (D  2008-03-09 21:38:26 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Gene Ward Smith <gene@  2008-03-09 19:02:06 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-03-09 19:09:43 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Brion K. Lienhart&q  2008-03-11 12:46:28 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Gene Ward Smith <gene@  2008-03-11 20:19:15 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Dimensional Travele  2008-03-11 14:43:56 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Don Bruder <dakidd@[EM  2008-03-11 15:01:45 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Dimensional Travele  2008-03-11 22:27:15 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (D  2008-03-09 21:36:26 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
mvp@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (M  2008-03-14 23:03:25 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Matt Browne SFW <matt.  2008-03-09 10:58:59 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-03-09 18:11:55 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Joetheone" <  2008-03-09 19:16:04 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-09 16:45:10 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-10 14:44:04 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-10 15:49:42 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 15:18:15 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-11 17:04:46 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 17:54:00 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-11 18:35:51 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 19:06:48 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-03-10 19:03:56 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Don Bruder <dakidd@[EM  2008-03-09 12:31:19 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
claylonnie@[EMAIL PROTECT  2008-03-09 11:37:27 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Don Bruder <dakidd@[EM  2008-03-09 12:26:36 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Gene Ward Smith <gene@  2008-03-09 19:32:00 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Don Bruder <dakidd@[EM  2008-03-09 13:07:20 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (D  2008-03-09 21:44:45 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Matthias Warkus <Warku  2008-03-09 20:27:42 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-09 17:31:03 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (D  2008-03-09 21:49:21 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-09 22:41:23 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Matthias Warkus <Warku  2008-03-10 21:03:46 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 15:28:05 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (D  2008-03-12 02:45:43 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-03-12 10:10:37 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-12 08:55:44 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
wdstarr@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-10 19:48:39 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Matthias Warkus <Warku  2008-03-11 11:36:53 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
throopw@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-10 02:50:30 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-03-10 03:30:19 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Martha Adams"   2008-03-10 17:47:12 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-10 14:39:52 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Gene Ward Smith <gene@  2008-03-10 19:54:41 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Charlton Wilbur <cwilb  2008-03-10 16:22:38 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Howard Brazee <howard@  2008-03-10 18:31:12 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-10 20:21:57 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
nebusj-@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-11 15:46:50 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 15:45:13 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-11 17:12:33 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 18:20:50 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (D  2008-03-12 02:47:35 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-12 07:48:08 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 15:43:45 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
John Schilling <schill  2008-03-11 18:09:12 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 22:46:09 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
wdstarr@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-10 20:45:40 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 15:48:20 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Howard Brazee <howard@  2008-03-11 17:27:50 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 19:11:40 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
wdstarr@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-13 00:24:40 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-13 04:47:32 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Matthias Warkus <Warku  2008-03-13 16:29:07 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Bill Snyder <bsnyder@[  2008-03-13 10:38:05 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-13 10:58:54 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Don Bruder <dakidd@[EM  2008-03-10 12:05:00 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
johan.g.larson@[EMAIL PRO  2008-03-10 05:12:59 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Matthias Warkus <Warku  2008-03-10 15:07:40 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Joy Beeson <jbeeson@[E  2008-03-11 01:03:02 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Matthias Warkus <Warku  2008-03-11 11:33:00 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
wdstarr@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-10 19:49:55 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
ilya2@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-03-10 07:26:57 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
nebusj-@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-10 12:39:25 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-10 13:14:56 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-03-10 19:17:45 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
throopw@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-10 18:34:47 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
"Richard R. Hershber  2008-03-10 13:06:25 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
"Michael S. Schiffer  2008-03-11 21:25:37 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (D  2008-03-12 02:36:49 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-03-12 09:57:22 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-03-13 09:52:20 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
WaltBJ <waltbj01@[EMAI  2008-03-10 14:31:29 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Matthias Warkus <Warku  2008-03-11 00:41:15 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (D  2008-03-11 03:17:09 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
"Dimensional Travele  2008-03-11 01:57:15 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-03-11 20:29:03 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 15:49:51 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
WaltBJ <waltbj01@[EMAI  2008-03-10 14:47:02 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
wdstarr@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-10 20:40:07 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Dimensional Travele  2008-03-11 02:00:17 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
wdstarr@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-12 00:45:54 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Gene Ward Smith <gene@  2008-03-12 04:49:43 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
wdstarr@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-12 00:56:36 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Gene Ward Smith <gene@  2008-03-12 06:28:11 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"Robert A. Woodward&  2008-03-11 23:31:26 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
jdnicoll@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-03-12 14:03:27 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
scott@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-03-10 23:35:02 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
johan.g.larson@[EMAIL PRO  2008-03-10 18:30:24 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Matthias Warkus <Warku  2008-03-11 11:41:19 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
John Schilling <schill  2008-03-11 18:09:12 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Howard Brazee <howard@  2008-03-11 17:22:01 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
"John F. Eldredge&qu  2008-03-11 01:52:21 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 15:38:48 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
scott@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-03-11 23:45:25 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-11 19:10:16 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Howard Brazee <howard@  2008-03-11 17:23:48 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
John Schilling <schill  2008-03-11 18:09:12 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Jasper Janssen <jasper  2008-03-11 14:21:49 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Crown-Horned Snorkack <  2008-03-11 10:11:24 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
throopw@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-12 05:09:53 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
johan.g.larson@[EMAIL PRO  2008-03-12 04:35:40 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-03-12 17:15:19 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-12 15:05:04 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
"David V. Loewe, Jr&  2008-03-12 15:19:23 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-12 17:02:25 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
johan.g.larson@[EMAIL PRO  2008-03-12 04:54:21 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of ?
nance@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-03-12 14:09:11 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
John Schilling <schill  2008-03-12 18:54:53 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of E
Walter Bushell <proto@  2008-03-13 09:34:26 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
throopw@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-12 18:09:01 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-03-13 00:18:34 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Greg Egan <gregegan@[E  2008-03-13 20:20:14 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Gene Ward Smith <gene@  2008-03-14 03:26:43 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Bryan Derksen <bryan.d  2008-03-14 04:02:30 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
goldfarb@[EMAIL PROTECTED  2008-03-14 07:54:16 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Matt Browne SFW <matt.  2008-03-16 03:58:38 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
"Brion K. Lienhart&q  2008-03-16 11:12:22 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
"Joel Olson" &l  2008-03-16 20:52:28 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
mb.gadw@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-03-30 10:37:40 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Larry Caldwell <firstn  2008-03-30 13:27:49 
Re: Comet impact in the Eastern United States - Feasibility of
Matt Browne SFW <matt.  2008-03-30 10:40:37 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Mon Dec 1 16:02:10 CST 2008.