|
|
| Science Fiction > Written > Re: Arthur C Cl... |
|
| << Topic |
< Post |
Post 28 of 142 Topic 20683 of 21906
|
Post > |
Topic >> |
Re: Arthur C Clarke, RIP
by Peter Knutsen <peter@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
Mar 19, 2008 at 11:10 AM
| Gene Ward Smith wrote:
> Peter Knutsen <peter@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in news:47e09343$0$15891
>>Different people use different definitions of science fiction. My point
>>remians that I've never come across a definition of science fiction that
>>excludes Clarke, whereas there are definitions that excludes Bradbury -
>>mine for instance.
>
> I don't believe you. Give your defintion and we'll see.
Mine is that the writer must be science-literate. Even if he writes
something that isn't hard science, he has to be able to know when he's
being good and when he's being naughty.
Now, what I'd really like to see is a definition of science fiction that
excludes Clarke. Even a half way serious one.
--
Peter Knutsen
sagatafl.org
|
142 Posts in Topic:
|
Thomas Womack <twomack |
2008-03-18 21:49:37 |
|
mimus <tinmimus99@[EMA |
2008-03-18 17:59:45 |
|
Luna <lunachick@[EMAIL |
2008-03-18 18:49:38 |
|
"Mike Schilling&quo |
2008-03-18 22:00:45 |
|
AndrewHall <andrewhall |
2008-03-18 15:05:06 |
|
Simon Morden <simon.mo |
2008-03-18 22:54:33 |
|
LawrencePerson@[EMAIL PRO |
2008-03-18 15:43:31 |
|
jerry_friedman@[EMAIL PRO |
2008-03-18 22:24:32 |
|
Sea Wasp <seawaspObvio |
2008-03-19 09:10:37 |
|
Wim Lewis <wiml@[EMAIL |
2008-03-18 22:51:30 |
|
"Sheerluck" < |
2008-03-19 09:56:40 |
|
nebusj-@[EMAIL PROTECTED] |
2008-03-18 19:18:13 |
|
yosef <ykerzner@[EMAIL |
2008-03-18 20:36:35 |
|
Jon Schild <jjs@[EMAIL |
2008-03-18 17:26:15 |
|
lal_truckee <lal_truck |
2008-03-19 00:19:38 |
|
mimus <tinmimus99@[EMA |
2008-03-18 20:23:46 |
|
Andrew Plotkin <erkyra |
2008-03-19 00:50:02 |
|
mimus <tinmimus99@[EMA |
2008-03-18 21:22:57 |
|
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(D |
2008-03-18 22:07:13 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 01:41:32 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 02:52:24 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 01:59:30 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 04:17:58 |
|
ted@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(T |
2008-03-19 03:43:21 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 05:14:59 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 04:20:41 |
|
Bill Snyder <bsnyder@[ |
2008-03-19 02:24:10 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 11:10:00 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 11:12:59 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 13:18:31 |
|
"Michael S. Schiffer |
2008-03-19 15:16:54 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 18:31:53 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 18:29:54 |
|
tmcd@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
( |
2008-03-19 22:16:15 |
|
"Default User" |
2008-03-19 23:03:11 |
|
David T. Bilek <davidb |
2008-03-19 22:14:19 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 11:14:08 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 13:19:38 |
|
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(D |
2008-03-19 10:00:35 |
|
Amanda <chicagofish@[E |
2008-03-20 21:09:45 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-21 03:04:07 |
|
"W. Citoan" < |
2008-03-21 20:36:46 |
|
Amanda <chicagofish@[E |
2008-03-21 20:55:02 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-21 21:02:04 |
|
"W. Citoan" < |
2008-03-21 21:40:46 |
|
"pullo" <pul |
2008-03-21 18:08:44 |
|
Amanda <chicagofish@[E |
2008-03-21 02:02:20 |
|
Sean O'Hara <seanohara |
2008-03-19 09:56:15 |
|
"Dimensional Travele |
2008-03-19 13:46:51 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 04:15:09 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 11:10:50 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 11:15:34 |
|
David T. Bilek <davidb |
2008-03-19 22:18:35 |
|
Amanda <chicagofish@[E |
2008-03-21 01:57:21 |
|
Howard Brazee <howard@ |
2008-03-19 06:02:59 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 13:21:46 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 13:24:54 |
|
Rebecca Rice <philosph |
2008-03-19 18:06:42 |
|
Kurt Busiek <kurt@[EMA |
2008-03-19 17:19:23 |
|
Howard Brazee <howard@ |
2008-03-19 18:37:30 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 18:35:09 |
|
"Christopher Adams&q |
2008-03-20 03:41:24 |
|
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(D |
2008-03-20 05:16:25 |
|
tmcd@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
( |
2008-03-20 20:29:11 |
|
acwheele@[EMAIL PROTECTED |
2008-03-20 19:38:32 |
|
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(D |
2008-03-19 08:43:23 |
|
Amanda <chicagofish@[E |
2008-03-21 01:54:52 |
|
John Schilling <schill |
2008-03-21 18:06:49 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-22 01:17:41 |
|
"W. Citoan" < |
2008-03-22 12:48:05 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-22 18:21:28 |
|
"W. Citoan" < |
2008-03-22 18:35:18 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-22 18:38:07 |
|
"W. Citoan" < |
2008-03-22 19:01:22 |
|
"Mike Schilling" |
2008-03-22 12:02:37 |
|
Bill Snyder <bsnyder@[ |
2008-03-22 15:46:22 |
|
"Mike Schilling" |
2008-03-23 02:54:40 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-22 19:05:32 |
|
Kurt Busiek <kurt@[EMA |
2008-03-22 12:11:20 |
|
"W. Citoan" < |
2008-03-22 20:06:55 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-22 20:11:02 |
|
Kurt Busiek <kurt@[EMA |
2008-03-22 13:27:55 |
|
Kurt Busiek <kurt@[EMA |
2008-03-22 13:31:35 |
|
Howard Brazee <howard@ |
2008-03-22 18:00:44 |
|
David Harmon <source@[ |
2008-03-22 15:23:12 |
|
"W. Citoan" < |
2008-03-23 03:27:47 |
|
Howard Brazee <howard@ |
2008-03-22 17:58:45 |
|
Howard Brazee <howard@ |
2008-03-22 17:56:00 |
|
Sea Wasp <seawaspObvio |
2008-03-22 20:45:40 |
|
Kurt Busiek <kurt@[EMA |
2008-03-22 17:47:22 |
|
Kurt Busiek <kurt@[EMA |
2008-03-22 11:50:50 |
|
Howard Brazee <howard@ |
2008-03-22 17:54:06 |
|
Walter Bushell <proto@ |
2008-03-22 10:47:56 |
|
"Mike Schilling" |
2008-03-18 19:03:15 |
|
Andrew Plotkin <erkyra |
2008-03-19 02:21:06 |
|
Howard Brazee <howard@ |
2008-03-18 20:35:27 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 02:46:47 |
|
"Mike Schilling" |
2008-03-18 21:01:09 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 04:17:00 |
|
"Mike Schilling" |
2008-03-19 04:45:00 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 11:12:16 |
|
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(D |
2008-03-19 08:48:05 |
|
Peter Knutsen <peter@[ |
2008-03-19 13:25:50 |
|
"Christopher Adams&q |
2008-03-19 04:06:47 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 04:23:14 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 04:51:15 |
|
"Christopher Adams&q |
2008-03-20 03:37:49 |
|
Howard Brazee <howard@ |
2008-03-19 16:57:55 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 23:01:33 |
|
"Christopher Adams&q |
2008-03-20 03:46:36 |
|
fairwater@[EMAIL PROTECTE |
2008-03-19 23:19:27 |
|
Howard Brazee <howard@ |
2008-03-19 18:39:40 |
|
"Mike Schilling" |
2008-03-18 20:59:17 |
|
Rich Horton <rrhorton@ |
2008-03-19 01:58:27 |
|
Sean O'Hara <seanohara |
2008-03-18 21:52:54 |
|
Amanda <chicagofish@[E |
2008-03-21 01:53:29 |
|
Butch Malahide <fred.g |
2008-03-18 23:57:18 |
|
Gene Ward Smith <gene@ |
2008-03-19 08:43:09 |
|
dbd@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
(D |
2008-03-19 08:41:49 |
|
mimus <tinmimus99@[EMA |
2008-03-19 13:12:48 |
|
tu160@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
|
2008-03-18 17:59:07 |
|
"Joseph T Major" |
2008-03-18 20:52:50 |
|
"Steven L." < |
2008-03-18 21:56:48 |
|
yosef <ykerzner@[EMAIL |
2008-03-18 20:39:40 |
|
throopw@[EMAIL PROTECTED] |
2008-03-19 04:29:04 |
|
"Mike Schilling" |
2008-03-19 04:45:31 |
|
"Dimensional Travele |
2008-03-18 21:54:59 |
|
Omega <omega@[EMAIL PR |
2008-03-19 11:14:51 |
|
Al <aajiv@[EMAIL PROTE |
2008-03-19 05:19:20 |
|
throopw@[EMAIL PROTECTED] |
2008-03-19 18:37:32 |
|
2bfjdsla52kztwejndzdstsxl |
2008-03-19 12:29:08 |
|
Kurt Busiek <kurt@[EMA |
2008-03-19 12:40:18 |
|
Sean O'Hara <seanohara |
2008-03-19 19:24:31 |
|
William Hyde <wthyde19 |
2008-03-19 13:19:57 |
|
Sea Wasp <seawaspObvio |
2008-03-19 18:26:56 |
|
"Christopher Adams&q |
2008-03-20 03:43:48 |
|
Sea Wasp <seawaspObvio |
2008-03-20 07:49:45 |
|
William Hyde <wthyde19 |
2008-03-20 11:13:39 |
|
"Mike Schilling" |
2008-03-20 11:33:19 |
|
Sea Wasp <seawaspObvio |
2008-03-20 19:22:16 |
|
William Hyde <wthyde19 |
2008-03-23 12:07:54 |
|
wdstarr@[EMAIL PROTECTED] |
2008-03-23 21:37:52 |
|
Post A Reply:
|
|
|
|
