Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Science Fiction > Written > Re: Anyone read...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 20 of 39 Topic 20852 of 23003
Post > Topic >>

Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?

by Eric D. Berge <eric_berge @[EMAIL PROTECTED] hotmail.com.invalid> Apr 10, 2008 at 11:15 PM

On Mon, 7 Apr 2008 20:44:35 -0700 (PDT), Ahasuerus
<ahasuerus@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:

>On the other hand, it's easy to see how Steve's "discussion of the
>book[s] here" can eventually help convince a reader that the strength
>of his convictions is not always fully sup****ted by his command of the
>facts, something hinted at in the books. Admittedly, this is by no
>means uncommon in SF, but it can seriously damage the kind of WSOD
>that you need to enjoy world building scenarios, something that
>Stirling specializes in. Which is too bad since, as you say:
>
>> Now, Stirling is a vastly better writer than John Norman, but still...

AOL to that - I liked (some of) his books a good deal before I
encountered him on soc.history.what-if.

Now that I know how much of his own **** he believes, I find him
pretty nearly unreadable.  And creepy as hell.
 




 39 Posts in Topic:
Anyone read Stirling's latest?
prestorjon <prestorjon  2008-04-05 22:01:30 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
ravenlynne <ravenlynne  2008-04-06 07:21:45 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"Dan Goodman" &  2008-04-06 19:05:42 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
ravenlynne <ravenlynne  2008-04-07 07:23:05 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
cgoodin@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-04-07 21:22:50 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
John Schilling <schill  2008-04-07 18:51:25 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"Rick" <rikw  2008-04-11 12:42:26 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Gene Ward Smith <gene@  2008-04-11 17:49:01 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"Rick" <rikw  2008-04-11 15:37:24 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Georgiana Gates <ramro  2008-04-11 17:13:22 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"Rick" <rikw  2008-04-11 18:51:55 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Gene Ward Smith <gene@  2008-04-12 00:04:41 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"Rick" <rikw  2008-04-11 20:27:39 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"Mike stone" &l  2008-04-12 09:58:08 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"Rick" <rikw  2008-04-12 17:36:22 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"AJ" <tortur  2008-04-11 21:07:40 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Howard <rayc_hrc@[EMAI  2008-04-06 07:39:24 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
johan.g.larson@[EMAIL PRO  2008-04-06 08:02:34 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Ahasuerus <ahasuerus@[  2008-04-07 20:44:35 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Eric D. Berge <eric_be  2008-04-10 23:15:58 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
johan.g.larson@[EMAIL PRO  2008-04-08 03:56:40 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"Rick" <rikw  2008-04-11 12:41:11 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Howard <rayc_hrc@[EMAI  2008-04-11 20:49:31 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Ahasuerus <ahasuerus@[  2008-04-12 16:35:54 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
prestorjon <prestorjon  2008-04-24 17:02:42 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"pullo" <pul  2008-04-24 22:19:21 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
prestorjon <prestorjon  2008-04-24 17:14:01 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
cgoodin@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-04-28 17:49:27 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
prestorjon <prestorjon  2008-04-24 17:19:10 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
prestorjon <prestorjon  2008-04-24 17:52:36 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"pullo" <pul  2008-04-24 22:26:51 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
ffranco@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-04-28 13:02:10 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Steve <joatsimeon@[EMA  2008-06-03 22:34:27 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
prestorjon <prestorjon  2008-07-20 16:03:02 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
"Mike stone" &l  2008-07-21 07:16:27 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Jordan179 <JSBassior20  2008-07-21 03:42:03 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
Jordan179 <JSBassior20  2008-07-21 03:43:09 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
prestorjon <prestorjon  2008-08-25 15:14:41 
Re: Anyone read Stirling's latest?
prestorjon <prestorjon  2008-08-25 15:17:23 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Mon Dec 1 19:15:19 CST 2008.